Which AFI record is your favorite?

I think mine is still Crash Love, though it's closely followed by BSITS and STS

Sing the Sorrow and then DU

It honestly depends on my mood. When I'm feeling really angry, it's gotta be Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes. If I'm feeling silly, it's somewhere between Answer That and Very Proud of Ya. When I'm feeling kinda moody I go for Art of Drowning. When I'm feeling like I need some extra badassness I go for Black Sails. When I'm feeling nostalgic, I like Sing the Sorrow because it was my first album. When I want cold and moody, but with a dash of pop, its Decemberunderground. When I want something poppy and glam I go to Crash Love. Can't deciiiiiide on just one.

Perfectly understandable. I actually agree with what you're saying!

Sing the Sorrow will always be special to me but right now, I'm all over Crash Love.

Sing the Sorrow. Followed by Crash Love. Sing The Sorrow is just such a good record, from the intense lyrics, the amazing musicianship, even down to just the sheer mood and atmosphere.

Sing the Sorrow.
Totally unique and one of my all time favorites.

Sing the Sorrow followed by BSITS - it's very close though

Sing The Sorrow. <3

Sing the Sorrow cuz that's how I discovered them & when I am depressed. Really depends on my mood & what I am doing at the moment. I LOVE to play the entire AOD when I am at the gym. ATASF when I am mad at my in-laws and people with authorities Crash Love just makes me feel mature & watching the world from afar

It's very difficult for me to decide. I will say, however, that I definitely show preference to the last five albums. STS was the album that held me together when I was severely depressed, whereas DU assisted in getting me through a major breakup. That said, those two are especially dear to my heart.

Art of Drowning and Sing the Sorrow

I'm going to join a lot of others and say Sing the Sorrow. But! I do like hearing their early stuff, Answer That And Stay Fashionable. I just laugh sometimes.